Should You Opt Out of AI Resume Screening? Pros & Cons Explained

In today’s job market, your resume often goes through software before any human recruiter sees it. This software is usually called AI resume screening or an Applicant Tracking System (ATS). For many job seekers, this creates a lot of questions. One of the biggest is:

Should I opt out of AI resume screening?

If you have seen job applications where you can check a box to “opt out of automated screening”, it may feel like a big decision. But most people do not clearly understand what happens when they choose to stay in or opt out.

This article explains everything, so you can make the right choice for your situation.

What Is AI Resume Screening?

AI resume screening is the process where companies use software to read, filter, and score resumes before a human recruiter reviews them. Most large and medium companies use this software. The most common type is called an Applicant Tracking System (ATS).

 AI Resume Screening

How It Works

  1. A company posts a job description.
  2. Hundreds (sometimes thousands) of resumes arrive.
  3. The ATS scans each resume and looks for:
    • Skills listed in the job posting
    • Experience matching job requirements
    • Job titles and keywords
    • Education and certifications
  4. The software scores or ranks resumes.
  5. Only the top-ranked resumes are forwarded to a human recruiter.

That means if your resume does not match the keywords, it may never be seen.

 AI Resume Screening

Important Point

AI does not judge you personally. It simply matches text. If the job posting says “Project Management” and your resume says “Managed project tasks,” the system may not see it as a match.

AI Resume Screening

The system is literal and rule-based. It does not understand nuance unless trained to do so.

Want to know which AI tools actually help you land more interviews?

Before sending your next job application, explore our guide: Best AI Resume Tools Reddit Users Recommend (2025 Guide

Why Do Companies Use AI Resume Screening?

There are a few main reasons.

1. Too Many Applicants

One job post can receive:

  • 200+ applications for normal roles
  • 1,000+ for remote roles
  • 5,000+ for jobs at big companies

No recruiter can manually read every resume.

2. Faster Hiring

Companies want to fill jobs quickly. AI makes the early sorting fast.

3. Standardized Filtering

AI screens based on requirements, not personal feelings.

This is meant to reduce bias (though in reality, bias can still exist).

4. Organized Candidate Management

The ATS helps store and track resumes, interview notes, and hiring workflow in one place.

Should You Opt Out of AI Resume Screening?

This is the main question, and the answer depends on your situation.

When Opting Out Might Be a Good Choice

You can consider opting out when:

  1. You are applying to small companies or startups.
    These companies may read resumes manually anyway.
  2. The job is creative or portfolio-based (such as designer, writer, videographer, animator).
    Your portfolio matters more than keyword matching.
  3. You already have a referral inside the company.
    An employee or hiring manager may forward your resume directly.

In these cases, opting out may help your resume reach a human faster.

AI Resume Screening

When You Should NOT Opt Out

You should not opt out when:

  1. You are applying to large companies (tech firms, banks, corporations).
  2. The role is technical (engineer, analyst, developer).
  3. The job posting has strict required skills.

In these cases, opting out may reduce your chance of being considered.
Your resume might go into a slow manual queue that no one reviews.

Curious about how AI agents like ChatGPT are reshaping hiring and automation?

Dive deeper into the tech side of AI with our breakdown of ChatGPT Agent Mode: What It Is and How It Works

Pros and Cons of AI Resume Screening

ProsCons
Speeds up hiringCan reject strong candidates due to formatting errors
Helps filter large applicant poolsRelies heavily on keyword matching
Reduces some forms of manual biasCan reinforce hidden algorithmic bias
Creates structured candidate evaluationCan ignore soft skills and potential

The system is not perfect, but it is becoming the industry standard.

AI Resume Screening

How to Know If a Job Uses AI Screening

You can usually tell by:

  • The application form used (Workday, Taleo, Lever, Greenhouse, etc.).
  • The job posting is on large job boards (Indeed, LinkedIn Jobs, Glassdoor).
  • The company is mid-sized or large.
  • You never interact with a human during the early process.

If you see an option that says:

  • “Allow automated processing of your resume”
  • “Use AI screening”
  • “Share data for automated evaluation”

It means the company uses an ATS.

What Happens If You Click “Opt Out”?

If you opt out:

  • Your resume may be placed in a manual review queue.
  • A human may review it but only if they have time.
  • Your application may move slower.
  • In some companies, manual review queue is never checked due to workload.

So opting out can mean:

  • More personal review, but also
  • Higher chance of being ignored

How to Improve Your Resume So AI Selects It

This is the most important part.

If your resume is not formatted correctly, AI may read it incorrectly. So let’s fix that.

1. Use Keywords from the Job Description

Look at the skills mentioned in the job posting and include the exact words in your resume.

Example:

If the job description says:

  • “Project management”
  • “Client communication”
  • “Data reporting”

Make sure these terms appear in your resume exactly.

2. Use a Simple, Clean Format

Do not use:

  • Images
  • Tables
  • Graphics
  • Text boxes
  • Icons

Use:

  • Plain text
  • Clear headings
  • Bullet points

3. Use Standard Job Titles

Bad: “Customer Happiness Hero”
Good: “Customer Support Specialist”

AI understands “Marketing Manager” more clearly than “Brand Growth Champion” or “Marketing Ninja”.

Be carefull on this.

4. Save as Word (.docx) Unless Otherwise Stated

Some ATS struggle with PDFs.

5. Use Strong Action Verbs

Examples:

  • Led
  • Managed
  • Designed
  • Improved
  • Analyzed

Before and After Example

Before (Weak)After (AI + Human Friendly)
Helped with marketing.Managed 3 digital marketing campaigns and increased leads by 25%.

Numbers help AI understand your impact.

Need quick, high-quality answers for applications, emails, or interview prep?

Check out Top AI Answer Generators You Need to Try in 2025

What Happens If You Select “Opt Out”?

Many job portals give you this option. But what does it actually mean?

If you opt out:

  • Your resume may go to a manual review queue
  • Manual review may take longer
  • In some cases, your resume may never be reviewed

So opting out can lower your chances, especially in large companies.

This is why the safer decision for most job seekers is:
Do not opt out, optimize instead.

Real-World Case Study that How to Get a Chance

Two job seekers applied for the same marketing job:

Candidate ACandidate B
Did not optimize resume for AIUsed keywords and clear formatting
Opted out of AI screeningPassed AI screening
Never heard backReceived interview within 10 days

The difference?
Candidate B worked with the system instead of avoiding it.

This happens more often than most job seekers realize.

Are AI Resume Screeners Fair?

Not always.

AI can be biased if:

  • Data used to train it was biased.
  • Job descriptions include biased language.
  • Screening rules favor certain backgrounds.

However, AI does help reduce:

  • Nepotism
  • Personal favoritism
  • Emotional bias

The best approach is to work with AI, not against it.

Decision Checklist

If You…You Should…
Apply to large corporate jobsDo not opt out. Optimize your resume.
Apply to startups or small companiesYou may opt out if networking.
Have a referralYou can opt out and send resume directly.
Rely mainly on portfolioOpt out and highlight portfolio links.

Best Practices to Improve Your Chances

Network on LinkedIn

LinkedIn is one of the best places to make job connections. Try to connect with people who work in the companies you are interested in. Like their posts, leave friendly comments, or send a short message saying you admire their work.

When someone inside a company knows you, your resume is more likely to be seen and sometimes can skip the AI filter.

Ask Recruiters About Their Hiring Process

Different companies use AI in different ways. Some use it a lot, some only a little. You can politely ask the recruiter questions like:

“Do you use AI to screen resumes?” or
“Is there a preferred resume format?”

This shows you are serious and helps you create a resume that fits what they are looking for.

Follow Up After You Apply

Many people send a job application and then never check back. Following up makes you stand out.
After 3–7 days, send a short message like:

“Hello, I recently applied for the [Job Title] position. I’m very interested. Just checking if there are any updates. Thank you.”

This small step shows interest and can help your application move forward.

Frequently Asked Questions Related AI Resume Screening

Q1. What is AI resume screening?

AI resume screening is when software analyzes resumes to check if they match a job’s requirements.

Q2. Can I bypass AI screenings?

You can, but bypassing often reduces your chances in large companies.

Q3. How do I make my resume AI-friendly?

Use keywords, clear formatting, and measurable achievements.

Q4. Is AI hiring fair?

AI removes some biases but may still reflect biases in training data.

Conclusion

So, should you opt out of AI resume screening?

For most people, the answer is no.

AI resume screening is now a standard part of hiring. Instead of trying to avoid it, it is better to learn how to work with it.

By using clear formatting, matching keywords, and highlighting measurable achievements, you increase your chances of being selected by both software and humans.

Leave a Comment